VRAM access timing/Emulation

openMSX

openMSX (18.0) supports VRAM access time emulation with the following limitations:

• In the default mode (display and sprites enable), it is a little too optimistic, i.e. within about 1~2 t-states, accesses that will work on openMSX will not work on a real machine. For example, on a Philips NMS 8250, an access with an interval of 19 t-states will work on openMSX but may fail on a real machine.
• With display disabled, it does not emulate at all the access time limitations of the non-bitmap display modes on V9938/58. This can be a major source of error, as this limitation doesn't exists on TMS9918 and don't seem to be documented.
• With sprites disabled, it still emulates too optimistically, sometimes with a 3 t-state gap between valid intervals in openMSX and those observed on a real machine. For example, while an access in graphics mode 1 with an interval of 12 t-states is valid in openMSX, it requires at least 15 t-states on a real machine.

Note: openMSX emulates quite faithfully write failures linked to a VDP command active on the same VRAM zone.

Emulicious

Emulicious (2023-04-22) has a limited emulation of VRAM access time:

• On TMS9918, a limitation exists for the default mode (display enabled) but it does not correspond to the value observed on a real machine. All screen modes seem to have an access limit of 25 t-states, whereas valid intervals are supposed to be 12 t-states for Text 1 mode and 29 for the others.
• On the other hand, with the screen off, access times are correct.
• On V9938/58, no limitation seems to be emulated at all.

Note: A forthcoming version of Emulicious should enable more precise emulation of VDP access timing.

Others

Other emulators do not emulate VDP access timing constraints at all: fMSX (6.0), blueMSX (2.8.2), MEISEI (1.3.2), RuMSX (0.83) and WebMSX (6.0.4).